ABOUT 17 HOURS AGO • 5 MIN READ

Friday Finds — Why "Required" Backfires Before Anyone Opens the Course

profile

Friday Finds

Spend 10 minutes. Walk away with actionable ideas you can use Monday morning in your L&D program.

Friday Finds

Fresh ideas, practical tools, and marketing-inspired thinking for people who design learning.

I'm excited for my daughter. She heads to Pitt in a few weeks for her freshman year, and I'm not worried about her for a second. She's ready. Me? I'm much less sure about that.

If I weren't a little sad and a little unsure right now, something would actually be wrong. Missing them is the tax you pay for loving people this much, and honestly, I'll pay it happily.

So if you see me around, I'd gladly take a hug. 8)

Thanks for reading!

🎵 Today I'm listening to Louis Armstrong

Supported by iSpring

Onboarding gets harder to scale the moment your business grows faster than your training process. This is where iSpring Suite AI can help. You can turn existing content into modern courses, add branching scenarios and role-play practice, build quick knowledge checks, and translate everything into 70+ languages without dragging production out for weeks.

Try iSpring Suite AI free for 14 days →


Stop Calling It Mandatory Training

An email lands in your inbox with the subject line: Mandatory Annual Compliance Training—Complete by Friday.

Before you open it, you already know the plot: a slow march through policy slides, a quiz designed to prove you were technically present, and perhaps a cheerful stock photo of coworkers pointing at a laptop.

The course may surprise you. But the label may already be working against it.

“Mandatory” tells people why the organization needs the training completed. It does not tell them why the training matters, what problem it will help solve, or what they will be able to do afterward.

That is an administrative fact, not a value proposition. And yet we keep putting it in the headline.

The Requirement Is Fixed. The Framing Is Not.

People do not approach training as blank slates. They make fast judgments before the first screen loads. Will this be useful or irrelevant? Worth my attention or safe to skim?

The word mandatory makes that judgment easier. It places the training in the same mental bucket as expense reports, password resets, and forms that need three signatures. It answers the organization’s question—Do you have to do this?—while ignoring the learner’s question: What will this help me do, avoid, or understand?

A mandate may secure participation. It does not guarantee the motivation needed to learn or apply anything.

That is why required learning still needs positioning. Marketers rarely lead with the least appealing part of an offer. A gym does not advertise, “Pay us to sweat before work.” A financial planner does not promise, “Several forms and an uncomfortable discussion about death.” They lead with the outcome: more energy, less stress, a safer future.

Learning teams should do the same. You do not need to hide the requirement. You simply need to demote it. Lead with the reason to care, then include the deadline and completion rules as supporting details.

Change the Frame

Compare these announcements:

Before: Complete Cybersecurity Training
After: Protect Your Team From the Attacks Employees See Most Often

Before: Annual Code of Conduct Training
After: Know What to Do When the Right Choice Is Not Obvious

Before: Required Manager Training
After: Handle Difficult Performance Conversations Without Making Them Worse

Before: Mandatory Data Privacy Course
After: Avoid the Small Data Mistakes That Create Big Problems

Nothing about the requirement changed. The stronger versions simply make a more useful promise.

They give people something concrete to care about: a threat, a decision, a mistake, or an action they will be better prepared to take. The message shifts from “the company wants this” to “this could help me.”

Of course, the promise must also be true. Do not advertise the “most common attacks” if the course never identifies them. Positioning is not decoration. It is a clear and honest connection between what people need and what the learning experience delivers.

Four Better Ways In

When you write your next training announcement, try entering through one of these four doors. They overlap, and that is fine. Choose the one that offers the strongest truthful reason to care.

Relevance: Where will people use this?

Spot the phishing tactics appearing in employee inboxes.

Risk: What costly mistake can they avoid?

Learn the warning signs that can prevent one rushed click from exposing customer data.

Benefit: What becomes easier, safer, or less painful?

Prepare for performance conversations that are clearer and fairer for everyone.

Action: What will people be able to do?

Submit expenses correctly the first time and avoid delays or rejected reports.

Notice that none of these promises fun. They promise usefulness, which is a much better bargain.

Positioning cannot turn a bad course into a good one. Clever copy attached to a bloated click-through course is not marketing; it is camouflage. But poor positioning can make genuinely useful training feel worthless before it begins.

Also supported by Neovation

The 7 Essential AI Prompting Habits webinar runs Wednesday, July 29 at 1 pm ET / 12 pm CT / 10 am PT, and it asks nothing of you beforehand: no prep, no technical background.

In 1 hour, you leave with the habits and a prompt toolkit you can use the same day. Can't make it live? Register anyway, and the recording will be sent to you.

Last chance to register →

The Five-Second Test

Before you publish your next announcement, remove the words mandatory, required, compliance, and complete. Then read what remains.

Can someone tell why the training matters? Can they picture a situation where it might help? Is there a clear risk, benefit, or useful action?

Most importantly, would the message have any pull if nobody were tracking completion?

If not, you have written an instruction rather than a reason to pay attention. You may still get a green completion dashboard, but do not confuse that with learning.

Try This This Week

Find one announcement that begins with Required, Mandatory, or Complete. Rewrite its headline around relevance, risk, benefit, or action.

Keep the requirement in the message. Just stop asking it to do the work of the value proposition.

The course may have to be mandatory. The boredom does not.


Go Deeper

Your Brain Hears "Must" and Pushes Back

Tell someone they have to do something, and part of their brain starts hunting for the exit — before they know what "it" even is. This study names that reflex and measures how much resistance is decided before your content loads.

When "Required" Backfires

Harvard researchers tracked 800+ companies for years. Mandatory diversity training didn't just stall — representation for some groups actually dropped. Voluntary training, same content, moved the needle up. The label wasn't neutral. It was the damage.

L&D Is Already Ditching "Compliance"

You're not the only one side-eyeing your subject lines. This piece makes the case for dropping "compliance" language for good — the word signals obedience, not value — and smart teams are rebuilding around what employees actually get.


The Bottom Line

Required training still needs to earn attention. A mandate can get someone into the course, but it cannot make the content feel relevant, useful, or worth remembering.

Be clear that the training is required. Just do not confuse the requirement with the reason to care. Lead with the problem it helps solve, the risk it reduces, or the action people will be better prepared to take. Then add the deadline.

The requirement may be fixed. The framing is not.

📍Where I'll be next

P.S. Know someone who would find this helpful?

The best way to support Friday Finds is to pass it on. Forward this email to a friend and invite them to join 3,000+ other readers at miketaylor.kit.com

(Already subscribed? You can grab my book, buy me a coffee, or book me to speak at your company.)

600 1st Ave, Ste 330 PMB 92768, Seattle, WA 98104-2246
Unsubscribe · Preferences

Friday Finds

Spend 10 minutes. Walk away with actionable ideas you can use Monday morning in your L&D program.